internal
Timothy G. NeCastro
President & Chief Executive Officer
Executive
12 yr
24 reports
Erie Insurance Group ·ERIE
Mutual insurer run through publicly traded management company
Financials · Fortune #323 · Hybrid structure · 7K employees · Erie, Pennsylvania
7
CEO span
↓ tighter than peers (avg 10)
3.1
Avg span
moderate
4
Max depth
4 levels
6.1 yr
Avg tenure
71%
Internal hires
↑ above industry avg
Interactive org chart
Erie Insurance Group organizational chart
Explore the executive structure, reporting layers, and scenario-ready operating model from public filings.
Open editable chart
Take this model into your AI workspace Use AI to reason through the model, then bring the scenario back into Creately Atlas.
Choose a prompt, then open an AI app and paste.
Download the CSV data instead
Erie Insurance Group is distinctive in being a mutual insurer managed by a publicly traded company. This page maps its enterprise, function-led structure, executive team, reporting depth, and compares Erie with other major P&C insurers.
What to model
Use the chart to test org decisions, not just view reporting lines
Start with the public baseline, then use the scenario views and source-backed changes to ask what happens when leadership, span, or team ownership shifts.
Latest signal Enterprise Operations Realignment changed role as Chief Operating Officer
Operations and claims functions consolidated under the COO in Jan 2025.
Source · See change logScenario views in the chart
- Add Chief AI & Data Officer Introduce a CAIO reporting to the CEO to centralize analytics and automation strategy.
- Shift Underwriting Under COO Move underwriting to report to the COO to tighten operational integration.
Atlas work this supports
- Connect Workday or UKG Get these analytics for YOUR org — tenure, span of control, headcount, automatically from your HRIS.
- Connect Salesforce Map your target accounts like this. Import contacts, visualize decision chains, plan multi-threading.
- Plan a Reorg Use this as a starting point. Model scenarios, compare structures, present options to your board.
The people
Who's running this
8 executives identified as Named Executive Officers in the most recent SEC proxy. Bar length scales with tenure.
John D. May
Executive Vice President & Chief Operating Officer
Operations
1 yr
3 reports
internal
Mark E. Stanczak
Executive Vice President & Chief Information Officer
Information Technology
5 yr
3 reports
internal
Christopher L. Langley
Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer
Finance
10 yr
3 reports
internal
Debra J. Kearns
Executive Vice President, Sales & Marketing
Sales & Marketing
6 yr
3 reports
internal
Douglas K. Smith
Senior Vice President & Chief Underwriting Officer
Underwriting
4 yr
3 reports
internal
Andrew C. McCullough
Executive Vice President, Secretary & General Counsel
Legal
7 yr
2 reports
internal
Annette M. McElhattan
Senior Vice President, Human Resources
Human Resources
8 yr
0 reports
The businesses
How Erie Insurance Group divides the work
4 divisions report into the group CEO. Tile size scales with estimated headcount.
Underwriting
1K employees
Senior Vice President & Chief Underwriting Officer (Douglas K. Smith)
Sets pricing, risk selection, and underwriting standards across personal and commercial lines.
Operations & Claims
3K employees
Executive Vice President & Chief Operating Officer (John D. May)
Manages claims, customer service, and operational efficiency enterprise-wide.
Information Technology
900 employees
Executive Vice President & Chief Information Officer (Mark E. Stanczak)
Supports core insurance systems, digital platforms, and cybersecurity.
Sales & Marketing
500 employees
Executive Vice President, Sales & Marketing (Debra J. Kearns)
Oversees independent agency distribution and brand marketing.
The thesis
Why this org is unusual
Erie Insurance Group’s most distinctive feature is that the mutual insurer is managed through a publicly traded management company, Erie Indemnity.
The CEO oversees a largely functional executive structure, with underwriting, operations, technology, and sales all reporting directly rather than through divisional P&L presidents. This concentrates control at the enterprise level.
The structure reflects Erie’s long-standing agency-based model and conservative growth strategy. Key risk, underwriting, and claims functions remain centralized, supporting consistency across states and products. Compared with stock insurers, Erie shows less divisional autonomy but deeper functional specialization.
Overall depth is moderate at four levels, with a relatively wide CEO span. This favors coordination and cost discipline over rapid product experimentation.
- Managed via publicly traded Erie Indemnity Company
- Centralized underwriting and operations
- High internal promotion among executives
The comparison
How Erie Insurance Group stacks up
Compared with peers like Travelers or Progressive, Erie Insurance Group maintains a more centralized, function-led structure with fewer autonomous business-unit heads. Large stock insurers often split personal and commercial lines into semi-independent divisions. Erie’s mutual ownership allows longer executive tenures …
C-suite size
Reporting depth
Erie Insurance Group
4 levels
5 levels
5 levels
6 levels
Chubb
6 levels
Avg C-suite tenure
Has COO / Has CAIO
Erie Insurance Group ✓ COO — no CAIO
Chubb ✓ COO — no CAIO
Current signals
What changed recently
The most significant recent change was the 2025 consolidation of operations and claims under the COO.
- Date not confirmed reorgEnterprise Operations Realignment Chief Operating Officer
Operations and claims functions consolidated under the COO in Jan 2025.
Source - Date not confirmed promoted
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the CEO of Erie Insurance Group?
Timothy G. NeCastro has served as President and CEO since 2013.
What type of organizational structure does Erie Insurance Group use?
Erie uses a centralized, function-led enterprise structure managed through Erie Indemnity.
How many direct reports does Erie Insurance Group's CEO have?
The CEO has seven direct executive reports.
How has Erie Insurance Group's leadership changed recently?
Recent changes include a 2025 operations realignment and a 2024 CIO promotion.
Is Erie Insurance Group known for internal promotions?
Yes, most executives, including the CEO and CFO, were promoted internally.
Sources
- Company Newsroom, Jan 2025
- Company Newsroom, Jul 2024
- SEC EDGAR: Erie Insurance Group DEF 14A Proxy Statement
- SEC EDGAR: Erie Insurance Group 10-K Annual Report
Reference
Cite this page
If you reference this page in research, analysis, or news writing, use one of the formats below. Citation includes the SEC filing source where applicable.
APA 7th
Creately. (2026). Erie Insurance Group organizational structure. Creately. Retrieved , from https://creately.com/org-chart/fortune-500/erie-insurance-group/MLA 9th
"Erie Insurance Group Organizational Structure." Creately, April 1, 2026, https://creately.com/org-chart/fortune-500/erie-insurance-group/. Accessed .Chicago 17
Creately. "Erie Insurance Group Organizational Structure." Last modified April 1, 2026. https://creately.com/org-chart/fortune-500/erie-insurance-group/.Permanent URL: https://creately.com/org-chart/fortune-500/erie-insurance-group/ · last updated 2026-04-01