What is Project Evaluation? The Complete Guide with Templates

Updated on: 20 February 2024 | 8 min read
Link Copied!

Project evaluation is an important part of determining the success or failure of a project. Properly evaluating a project helps you understand what worked well and what could be improved for future projects. This blog post will provide an overview of key components of project evaluation and how to conduct effective evaluations.

What is Project Evaluation?

Project evaluation is a key part of assessing the success, progress and areas for improvement of a project. It involves determining how well a project is meeting its goals and objectives. Evaluation helps determine if a project is worth continuing, needs adjustments, or should be discontinued.

A good evaluation plan is developed at the start of a project. It outlines the criteria that will be used to judge the project’s performance and success. Evaluation criteria can include things like:

  • Meeting timelines and budgets - Were milestones and deadlines met? Was the project completed within budget?
  • Delivering expected outputs and outcomes - Were the intended products, results and benefits achieved?
  • Satisfying stakeholder needs - Were customers, users and other stakeholders satisfied with the project results?
  • Achieving quality standards - Were quality metrics and standards defined and met?
  • Demonstrating effectiveness - Did the project accomplish its intended purpose?

Project evaluation provides valuable insights that can be applied to the current project and future projects. It helps organizations learn from their projects and continuously improve their processes and outcomes.

Project Evaluation Templates

These templates will help you evaluate your project by providing a clear structure to assess how it was planned, carried out, and what it achieved. Whether you’re managing the project, part of the team, or a stakeholder, these template assist in gathering information systematically for a thorough evaluation.

Project Evaluation Template 1

Project Evaluation Template
Edit this Template
  • Ready to use
  • Fully customizable template
  • Get Started in seconds
exit full-screen Close

Project Evaluation Template 2

Project Evaluation Template
Edit this Template
  • Ready to use
  • Fully customizable template
  • Get Started in seconds
exit full-screen Close

Project Evaluation Methods

Project evaluation involves using various methods to assess the performance and impact of a project. The choice of methods depends on the nature of the project, its objectives, and the available resources. Here are some common project evaluation methods:

Pre-project evaluation

Pre-project evaluations are done before a project begins. This involves evaluating the project plan, scope, objectives, resources, and budget. This helps determine if the project is feasible and identifies any potential issues or risks upfront. It establishes a baseline for later evaluations.

Project Charter Template
Edit this Template
  • Ready to use
  • Fully customizable template
  • Get Started in seconds
exit full-screen Close
Project charter template to assess project plan, scope, objectives, resources, and budget

Ongoing evaluation

Ongoing evaluations happen during the project lifecycle. Regular status reports track progress against the project plan, budget, and deadlines. Any deviations or issues are identified and corrective actions can be taken promptly. This allows projects to stay on track and make adjustments as needed.

Project Status Summary
Edit this Template
  • Ready to use
  • Fully customizable template
  • Get Started in seconds
exit full-screen Close
Project status template to assess project progress

Post-project evaluation

Post-project evaluations occur after a project is complete. This final assessment determines if the project objectives were achieved and customer requirements were met. Key metrics like timeliness, budget, and quality are examined. Lessons learned are documented to improve processes for future projects. Stakeholder feedback is gathered through surveys, interviews, or focus groups.

Project Post-Mortem Meeting Toolkit
Edit this Template
  • Ready to use
  • Fully customizable template
  • Get Started in seconds
exit full-screen Close
Project post-mortem meeting template to reflect on lessons learned

Project Evaluation Steps

When evaluating a project, there are several key steps you should follow. These steps will help you determine if the project was successful and identify areas for improvement in future initiatives.

Step 1: Set clear goals

The first step is establishing clear goals and objectives for the project before it begins. Make sure these objectives are SMART: specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound. Having clear goals from the outset provides a benchmark for measuring success later on.

Step 2: Monitor progress

Once the project is underway, the next step is monitoring progress. Check in regularly with your team to see if you’re on track to meet your objectives and deadlines. Identify and address any issues as early as possible before they become major roadblocks. Monitoring progress also allows you to course correct if needed.

Step 3: Collect data

After the project is complete, collect all relevant data and metrics. This includes both quantitative data like budget information, timelines and deliverables, as well customer feedback and qualitative data from surveys or interviews. Analyzing this data will show you how well the project performed against your original objectives.

Step 4: Analyze and interpret

Identify what worked well and what didn’t during the project. Highlight best practices to replicate and lessons learned to improve future initiatives. Get feedback from all stakeholders involved, including project team members, customers and management.

Step 5: Develop an action plan

Develop an action plan to apply what you’ve learned for the next project. Update processes, procedures and resource allocations based on your evaluation. Communicate changes across your organization and train employees on any new best practices. Implementing these changes will help you avoid similar issues the next time around.

Action Plan Template
Edit this Template
  • Ready to use
  • Fully customizable template
  • Get Started in seconds
exit full-screen Close
Action Plan Template

Benefits of Project Evaluation

Project evaluation is a valuable tool for organizations, helping them learn, adapt, and improve their project outcomes over time. Here are some benefits of project evaluation.

  1. Helps in making informed decisions by providing a clear understanding of the project’s strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement.
  2. Holds the project team accountable for meeting goals and using resources effectively, fostering a sense of responsibility.
  3. Facilitates organizational learning by capturing valuable insights and lessons from both successful and challenging aspects of the project.
  4. Allows for the efficient allocation of resources by identifying areas where adjustments or reallocations may be needed.
  5. Provides evidence of the project’s value by assessing its impact, cost-effectiveness, and alignment with organizational objectives.
  6. Involves stakeholders in the evaluation process, fostering collaboration, and ensuring that diverse perspectives are considered.

Project Evaluation Best Practices

Follow these best practices to do a more effective and meaningful project evaluation, leading to better project outcomes and organizational learning.

  1. Clear objectives: Clearly define the goals and questions you want the evaluation to answer.
  2. Involve stakeholders: Include the perspectives of key stakeholders to ensure a comprehensive evaluation.
  3. Use appropriate methods: Choose evaluation methods that suit your objectives and available resources.
  4. Timely data collection: Collect data at relevant points in the project timeline to ensure accuracy and relevance.
  5. Thorough analysis: Analyze the collected data thoroughly to draw meaningful conclusions and insights.
  6. Actionable recommendations: Provide practical recommendations that can lead to tangible improvements in future projects.
  7. Learn and adapt: Use evaluation findings to learn from both successes and challenges, adapting practices for continuous improvement.
  8. Document lessons: Document lessons learned from the evaluation process for organizational knowledge and future reference.

How to Use Creately to Evaluate Your Projects

Use Creately’s visual collaboration platform to evaluate your project and improve communication, streamline collaboration, and provide a visual representation of project data effectively.

Task tracking and assignment

Use the built-in project management tools to create, assign, and track tasks right on the canvas. Assign responsibilities, set due dates, and monitor progress with Agile Kanban boards, Gantt charts, timelines and more. Create task cards containing detailed information, descriptions, due dates, and assigned responsibilities.

Notes and attachments

Record additional details and attach documents, files, and screenshots related to your tasks and projects with per item integrated notes panel and custom data fields. Or easily embed files and attachments right on the workspace to centralize project information. Work together on project evaluation with teammates with full multiplayer text and visual collaboration.

Real-time collaboration

Get any number of participants on the same workspace and track their additions to the progress report in real-time. Collaborate with others in the project seamlessly with true multi-user collaboration features including synced previews and comments and discussion threads. Use Creately’s Microsoft Teams integration to brainstorm, plan, run projects during meetings.

Pre-made templates

Get a head start with ready-to-use progress evaluation templates and other project documentation templates available right inside the app. Explore 1000s more templates and examples for various scenarios in the community.

In summary, project evaluation is like a compass for projects, helping teams understand what worked well and what can be improved. It’s a tool that guides organizations to make better decisions and succeed in future projects. By learning from the past and continuously improving, project evaluation becomes a key factor in the ongoing journey of project management, ensuring teams stay on the path of excellence and growth.

More project management related guides

Join over thousands of organizations that use Creately to brainstorm, plan, analyze, and execute their projects successfully.

Get started here


author image
Amanda Athuraliya Communications Specialist

Amanda Athuraliya is the communication specialist/content writer at Creately, online diagramming and collaboration tool. She is an avid reader, a budding writer and a passionate researcher who loves to write about all kinds of topics.

linkedin icon
View all posts by Amanda Athuraliya →